The Piano Tutor by Maggie Hill

[It seems Kim and I are having fun writing and challenging each other, we now have a new fetlife along with another friend of ours we met online who has been inspired to write as well, our username is ShamefulWhispers, even made a logo for it, tell me what you guys think.]

Maggie Hill, an endearingly awkward 18-year-old tomboy, trudged into the house after another day of being mistaken for a boy by her classmates. The final straw was when the cute new girl asked her out, only to realize she wasn't a he. Enraged and humiliated, Maggie stomped to her room, slamming the door behind her. She flung open her dresser, rifling through the drawers in search of a distraction from her anger. Her fingers brushed against something unexpected - lacy, red underwear. Maggie's eyes widened as she recalled her older sister, Alexis, leaving them behind after a wild night out. With a mischievous glint in her eye, Maggie stripped off her baggy clothes and slipped into the provocative lingerie. The cool fabric against her skin made her shiver, and she couldn't help but touch herself, exploring the unfamiliar sensation of the silky material against her sensitive flesh.

Maggie's breath hitched as she rubbed her nipples, the friction of the lace against her sensitive buds sending jolts of pleasure coursing through her body. She arched her back, pressing her chest further into her hands, reveling in the new sensations the silk underwear provided. Her fingers danced lower, slipping beneath the waistband of her panties to tease the slick folds of her pussy. Maggie gasped, her thighs clenching together as she explored the wet heat between them. She circled her clit with a tentative touch, her hips rocking involuntarily as she chased the growing pleasure. Lost in the moment, Maggie failed to notice the time, the world outside her room fading away. Suddenly, a knock at the door jolted her back to reality. Her heart racing, she scrambled to cover herself, yanking on the first clothes she could find - a baggy shirt and oversized running shorts.

Panting slightly, Maggie yanked open the door, her heart pounding in her chest. She hadn't expected to see a young man on the other side, especially not one who looked to be around her age. Jeff, the name on his lips, seemed just as taken aback by her appearance. His eyes widened as they traveled down her form, taking in the baggy shirt and oversized shorts that did little to hide the curves of her body, still tinged with a flush from her recent arousal.

"Uh, hi," Maggie stammered, trying to regain her composure.

She could feel the silk of her underwear rubbing against her skin with every move, a constant reminder of her forbidden moment of self-discovery.

"I wasn't expecting a... a substitute tutor."

Jeff shifted awkwardly, breaking eye contact, "Yeah, my grandpa's not feeling well, so I'm filling in until he's better. I hope that's okay?"

Maggie's cheeks burned as she led Jeff to the piano, acutely aware of the revealing glimpses her outfit provided. The red bra peeking out from her shirt and the low neckline allowing him to catch a glimpse of her cleavage made her feel exposed and vulnerable. She could practically feel his gaze on her as they walked, the intensity of his stare making her fumble with the key to the piano.

"Here we are," she mumbled, pushing up the cover to reveal the piano keys.

Jeff moved to take a seat, and Maggie settled beside him, trying to ignore the way her body seemed to hum with an unfamiliar energy in his presence. As he began to guide her through the lesson, Maggie found herself struggling to focus on the music, her mind drifting back to the forbidden thrill of touching herself in her sister's lingerie.

Maggie's clumsiness struck again as she reached for Jeff's fallen phone, her arm knocking against his in the process. In a moment of haste, she bent over to retrieve it, her hand landing squarely on his thigh. The movement caused the waistband of her oversized shorts to slip down, exposing the tantalizing tops of her ass and the provocative red lace of her panties. As she stretched to grab the phone, Maggie's face inadvertently found itself nestled in Jeff's crotch, her mouth and nose rubbing against the base of his hardening cock. The sudden, intimate contact made her gasp, and she quickly pulled back, her hand still gripping the phone. Her eyes widened as she took in the scene, realizing where her hand now rested and the sizeable hardness she was holding.

Jeff's flushed face and embarrassed expression mirrored her own as she hastily apologized, "I'm so sorry, I didn't mean..."

Panic gripped Maggie as she stood up, desperate to escape the embarrassing situation. But in her haste, the baggy shorts slipped down her legs, revealing her bare skin and the provocative red lingerie beneath. In a moment of confusion, she spun around, thinking the fabric had caught on something, and collided with the piano. Her balance faltered, and she tumbled forward, her body crashing into Jeff's. In a bizarre twist of fate, her silk-covered crotch ended up pressed against his face, the intimate contact sending shockwaves through both of them. Jeff's eyes widened as he found himself nose to groin with Maggie, the scent of her arousal mingling with the heady fragrance of the silk. Maggie's face turned a deep shade of crimson as she struggled to regain her composure, her hands flailing wildly to right herself. The situation had spiraled out of control, and she could only pray for a miracle to salvage what was left of her dignity.

Jeff's hands shot up, attempting to help Maggie regain her balance, but in doing so, they found themselves under her baggy shirt, coming to rest squarely on her breasts. The thin fabric of her bra offered little barrier, the delicate lace and sheer material rendering it almost nonexistent. The intimate proximity and the shock of the touch made Jeff's heart race, his palms tingling against her soft skin. Maggie's mind reeled as she felt Jeff's hands on her, the warmth seeping through the thin barrier of her bra. Her body betrayed her, responding to the touch with a surge of heat and a sudden ache between her thighs. The image of her pussy pressed against his face and his hands cupping her breasts was seared into her mind, a forbidden fantasy come to life. She could only imagine how the scene must look from his perspective, her red lingerie on full display, her breasts heaving with each ragged breath.

"Ok, let's think about this and then move," Jeff said.

Jeff's muffled voice against Maggie's crotch seemed to echo through her mind as he pulled back, his face flushed with a mix of embarrassment and something else she couldn't quite name. He freed his hands from her breasts, but in the process, his watch caught on the inside of her shirt. Maggie's embarrassment turned to panic as she felt the fabric begin to tear, the pressure building as the watch pulled harder. She needed to escape, not just from the mortifying situation, but from the intense arousal that had taken hold of her. Being so close to Jeff, feeling his touch, his breath against her most intimate area, had ignited a fire within her that threatened to consume her. As she sidestepped around him, her shorts were left behind, the shirt tore further, and the watch finally released with a small ripping sound. Maggie had no choice but to let the garment go or risk falling again, leaving her in nothing but her sister's provocative red bra and panties.

Maggie's face burned with mortification as she stood before Jeff, her clothing in disarray, her body on full display in her sister's revealing lingerie. She expected ridicule, laughter, or at the very least, a look of disgust. But as she met his gaze, she was taken aback by the hunger she saw there. Jeff's eyes roamed over her form, drinking in the sight of her curves, the way the red bra pushed up her breasts, and the lace of her panties visible through the torn remnants of her shirt. Instead of mockery, his expression was one of desire, his eyes darkening with a primal need. Maggie's breath caught in her throat as she realized the effect, she was having on him, her embarrassment slowly giving way to a thrill of excitement. She had never been the object of such intense male attention before, and it was both terrifying and exhilarating.

With trembling hands, Maggie peeled off the last remnants of her shirt, leaving her clad in only the provocative red lingerie. Her heart pounded in her chest as she approached Jeff, a bold determination etched on her face. She straddled his lap, her thighs pressing against his as she captured his lips in a searing kiss. The taste of him, the feel of his mouth moving against hers, sent shockwaves of desire coursing through her body. Maggie's hands tangled in his hair, pulling him closer as she deepened the kiss, her tongue dancing with his in a sensual tango. The heat between them was palpable, the air thick with the scent of arousal and the promise of forbidden pleasure. As they broke for air, Maggie's breath came in ragged gasps, her eyes locked on Jeff's, a silent challenge and invitation in their depths. She was offering herself to him, body and soul, and she had no intention of taking no for an answer.

With a bold flourish, Maggie reached behind her back and unclasped the bra, letting it fall to the floor with a soft rustle. Her breasts bounced free, the rosy nipples already hard and aching for attention. Jeff's mouth trailed a scorching path from her lips to the sensitive skin of her neck, his tongue leaving a wet, tingling trail in its wake. As he reached her breasts, he circled a nipple with his tongue, sending jolts of pleasure straight to her core. Maggie's back arched, pressing her chest further into his mouth as she gasped his name. His hands cupped her breasts, thumbs teasing the nipples into even tighter peaks as he suckled and nibbled, drawing out her moans of pleasure. The heat of his mouth and the touch of his hands on her bare skin was almost too much to bear, and yet Maggie craved more, her body burning with a need she'd never known before.

Jeff's passion reached a fever pitch as he grasped Maggie's hips, lifting her effortlessly and setting her down on the piano keys with a loud, jarring sound. The sudden movement only added to the intensity of the moment, their bodies pressed together, skin to skin, as he pulled her panties down her legs. The lacy fabric joined her bra on the floor, leaving Maggie completely bare before him. With a primal growl, Jeff delved between her thighs, his tongue laving at her inner legs, inching closer to the source of her heat. Maggie's hands fisted in his hair, her hips bucking against his mouth as he reached the apex of her desire. His tongue flicked out, teasing her clit, and Maggie's back arched, a keening moan escaping her lips. Jeff intensified his efforts, suckling and nibbling, his fingers digging into the soft flesh of her thighs as he feasted on her arousal.

The piano keys sang out in discordant chaos as Maggie's hips moved in time with Jeff's ministrations, her ass rising and falling with each thrust of his fingers. The sound of the clashing notes mingled with her ragged breathing and the wet sounds of Jeff's mouth on her flesh, creating a symphony of primal desire. As he delved deeper, his fingers pumping in and out of her slick heat, Maggie's moans grew louder, her body trembling on the edge of release. Jeff's tongue swirled around her clit, teasing the sensitive bud as he fingered her, driving her closer to the precipice. The combined sensations were almost too much to bear, and yet Maggie craved more, her mind clouded with lust as she ground her pussy against Jeff's face.

Jeff's fingers pushed past Maggie's virgin barrier, sinking deep into her tight asshole as he added a third digit to the ones already pumping in and out of her pussy. The sudden invasion sent a shockwave of pleasure-pain through her, and Maggie's body seized up, her back arching as she came hard against Jeff's face. Her cries of ecstasy echoed through the room, mingling with the discordant notes of the piano as her hips jerked and twisted, lost to the intensity of her climax. Her hands flew to her breasts, fingers twisting and pinching at the sensitive nipples as she rode out the waves of her orgasm. Jeff continued to work her through it, his tongue lashing at her clit, his fingers curling inside her as he milked her for every last tremor of pleasure. As the final aftershocks faded, Maggie collapsed back against the piano, her chest heaving, her skin slick with sweat.

Maggie's gaze locked onto Jeff's face as the realization of what he'd done dawned on him. She saw the shock, the guilt, the regret flickering in his eyes, and she knew she had to act fast to erase it. With a boldness she never knew she possessed, Maggie sank to her knees before him, her hands moving with a newfound confidence. She reached for his zipper, pulling it down with a deft tug, and then delved into his pants, fishing out the hard, thick length of his cock. It was her first time seeing one up close, her first time touching one, and yet it felt utterly natural as if her body had been made for this moment. Without hesitation, she wrapped her lips around the head, her tongue swirling around the sensitive tip as she took him deeper.

Maggie's throat constricted as Jeff's cock pushed past her lips, the girth and length stretching her mouth wide. She gagged on the intrusion, her eyes watering as she struggled to accommodate him. As she took more of him into her mouth, her nose buried in the coarse hair at the base, she marveled at the sheer size of it. Compared to her own fingers, it was enormous, a thick, heavy weight that filled her completely. She had no frame of reference to gauge its true size, only the overwhelming sensation of being utterly consumed by it. Despite the discomfort, Maggie found herself drawn to the power and masculinity it represented, her body responding with a primal hunger. She relaxed her throat, allowing Jeff to push deeper, her nose pressed against the wiry hairs as she swallowed around him, her tongue undulating along the shaft.

Maggie's hand wrapped around the base of Jeff's cock, her grip firm as she began to move her head in a steady rhythm. She raised up, the head popping free of her lips with a lewd pop, before sinking back down, her mouth enveloping him once more. Her tongue swirled around the shaft as she descended, lapping at the salty taste of his skin. The flavor was unlike anything she'd experienced before, a heady mix of musk and maleness that seemed to heighten her arousal. As the girls at school had warned, it wasn't sweet or pleasant, but there was a raw, primal appeal to it that Maggie found herself enjoying. She redoubled her efforts, sucking harder, her cheeks hollowing as she worked him with her mouth, her tongue flicking and teasing the sensitive underside.

"Maggie, wait," he pleaded, "oh, god."

Despite Jeff's protests, Maggie continued her relentless assault on his cock, driven by a newfound sense of confidence and desire. She could feel the twitch and pulse of his arousal in her mouth, the moans she coaxed from him only serving to fuel her own pleasure. As she sucked and licked, she reveled in the feeling of power and control, her body thrumming with a heady sense of accomplishment. But just as she thought she had him right on the edge, Jeff's cock suddenly spasmed in her mouth, his hips jerking as a torrent of hot, thick seed flooded her throat. Maggie's eyes widened in surprise, her mouth stretching to accommodate the unexpected volume. She swallowed reflexively, trying to gulp down every last drop as Jeff's cries of pleasure echoed through the room. As the final pulses subsided, Maggie slowly released his softening cock from her lips, a triumphant smile playing on her lips.

Maggie rose to her feet, her naked body on full display before Jeff once more. His gaze roamed over her, his eyes drinking in every curve and contour as if committing her to memory. Then, with a tender touch, he cupped her face, his thumb brushing over her cheekbone as he pulled her in for a soft, lingering kiss. The gentleness of the moment was a stark contrast to the passion of their earlier encounter, and Maggie found herself melting into his embrace. As they parted, Jeff's hands began to wander, trailing down the column of her throat to her breasts. He palmed the soft mounds, his thumbs brushing over her nipples, making them pebble beneath his touch. Maggie's breath hitched, and she arched into his caress, her body responding instinctively to his touch. His hands continued their exploration, skating over her stomach, hips, and thighs, leaving a trail of heat in their wake.

Maggie rose to her feet, her naked body on full display before Jeff once more. His gaze roamed over her, his eyes drinking in every curve and contour as if committing her to memory. Then, with a tender touch, he cupped her face, his thumb brushing over her cheekbone as he pulled her in for a soft, lingering kiss. The gentleness of the moment was a stark contrast to the passion of their earlier encounter, and Maggie found herself melting into his embrace. As they parted, Jeff's hands began to wander, trailing down the column of her throat to her breasts. He palmed the soft mounds, his thumbs brushing over her nipples, making them pebble beneath his touch. Maggie's breath hitched, and she arched into his caress, her body responding instinctively to his touch. His hands continued their exploration, skating over her stomach, hips, and thighs, leaving a trail of heat in their wake.

Maggie's hips moved in slow, sensual circles, grinding her slick pussy against the rigid length of Jeff's cock. Her moans mingled with the kiss, a symphony of desire and need. The friction was delicious, Jeff's hardness rubbing against her clit with each pass, stoking the fire within her. Breaking the kiss, Maggie gazed down at Jeff with hooded eyes, her breath coming in ragged pants.

"I want you inside me," she whispered, her voice husky with lust, "Please, Jeff, I need it."

Without waiting for a response, Maggie reached between them, grasping Jeff's cock and positioning it at her entrance. She rocked her hips, pushing down, and with a cry of pleasure, she sank onto his length, taking him to the hilt.

"Oh god, oh god, oh fuck!" Maggie's scream echoed through the room as she impaled herself on Jeff's cock, the sudden intrusion making her eyes roll back in her head.

The sensation of being so full, so stretched, was almost overwhelming. She'd never felt anything like it before, the thickness and girth of him filling her completely. Jeff's hands gripped her hips tightly, his fingers digging into her skin as he struggled to control his own movements.

"You're so tight, Maggie," he gasped, his voice strained with pleasure, "I can barely move."

Maggie's nails dug into Jeff's shoulders as she started to rock her hips, her body adapting to the size of him. Each movement sent jolts of pleasure through her, the friction of his cock against her inner walls making her head spin. She'd never known it could feel this good, the pain of the initial penetration giving way to an intense, almost unbearable pleasure.

Jeff's hands tightened on Maggie's ass, his fingers sinking into the flesh as he began to move her up and down his cock. The pace was brutal, each thrust slamming her down onto him, taking her breath away. Maggie's back arched, her breasts bouncing with the force of his movements, as she met his strokes with equal fervor. The room filled with the sounds of skin slapping against skin, Maggie's cries of pleasure, and Jeff's grunts of effort as he fucked her hard and fast, losing himself in the sheer intensity of the moment. Maggie's inner walls clenched around Jeff's cock, her body responding to the relentless pounding. She could feel every ridge, every vein, as he drove into her, the sensation bordering on pain, yet somehow exquisite. Her mind clouded with lust, she surrendered to the pleasure, her hips grinding against him with reckless abandon.

"I'm close, I'm going to cum," Jeff warned her between gasps.

Jeff's warning only spurred Maggie on, her movements becoming more frantic as she felt the tension coiling within her. She could sense his impending climax, his cock throbbing inside her as he pounded into her with renewed vigor.

"Yes, Jeff, cum inside me," she begged, her voice a husky whisper, "Fill me up, make me yours."

The words seemed to trigger something in him, Jeff's thrusts becoming more erratic as he chased his release. Maggie could feel him swelling, his cock pulsing as he neared the edge. With a final, powerful shove, Jeff buried himself to the hilt, his seed erupting deep within her as he roared her name. Maggie's own climax crashed over her, her pussy clenching around him as waves of pleasure washed through her. She rode out the aftershocks, her body trembling in his arms, as Jeff's warmth flooded her, marking her as his.

Maggie's heart raced as the sudden knock at the door startled her and Jeff, their bodies still entwined. She disentangled herself from him, a gasp escaping her lips as his cock slipped free, the sensation a mix of pleasure and pain. In a daze, she stumbled towards the door, grabbing a towel from the laundry room on the way. Not thinking, she flung it around herself and yanked the door open, only to find her concerned neighbor on the other side.

"Hey Maggie, I was just checking if everything's okay," the woman said, her brow furrowed with worry.

Maggie's mind raced, trying to come up with an explanation for her disheveled state and the lingering scent of sex that clung to her skin.

"Uh, yeah, everything's fine," she stammered, hoping her neighbor wouldn't notice anything amiss, "Just, uh, took a shower."

Maggie's flustered state and the towel barely covering her lower half went unnoticed by her neighbor at first. However, as the woman's eyes lingered on her face, a flicker of something crossed her features, and Maggie's heart sank. She had no idea that in her haste to open the door, she had left her most intimate area on full display, the towel barely covering her slick, cum-leaking pussy. The realization hit her like a ton of bricks as her neighbor's gaze shifted downward, her eyes widening in surprise and then quickly darting away.

"I, uh, heard some loud noises and screams," the woman stammered, "wanted to make sure you were okay. I really should get back to dinner for my husband, though. Nice seeing you, Maggie."

With that, she turned and hurried off, leaving Maggie standing there in shock, the towel now seeming woefully inadequate to conceal the evidence of her recent activities.

"Everything ok," Jeff asked.

Jeff's voice cut through Maggie's stunned silence, and she whirled around to face him, her eyes wide with horror. As if mirroring her own thoughts, Jeff's gaze drifted down, and his jaw dropped as he took in the sight of her exposed, cum-streaked pussy. The realization of their precarious situation hit them both at the same time, the gravity of their predicament settling heavily in the air between them.

"Oh my god," Jeff breathed, his voice laced with shock and panic, "What have we done?"

Maggie could only stare at him, her mind reeling as she tried to process the chaos they'd unleashed. The sounds of their impassioned lovemaking, the screams, the pounding on the door - it all seemed so loud now, so reckless. And now, to top it off, her neighbor had seen the aftermath of their depravity, her own body bearing the evidence.

Jeff's suggestion hit home, and Maggie's eyes darted to the open door, her gaze falling on the tantalizing curve of her own ass, still on full display to anyone who might stroll by. A sudden giggle bubbled up in her throat, and she couldn't help but share it with Jeff, the absurdity of their situation washing over them both. They were two teenagers, caught in a compromising position, and now, thanks to their own carelessness, their neighbor had likely gotten an eyeful of Maggie's most intimate parts. The thought was both mortifying and hilarious, and they found themselves laughing, the tension in the room dissipating as they embraced the ridiculousness of it all.

Jeff's words hung in the air, a mix of amusement and incredulity.

"So, you treat all your tutors like this?" he asked, a smirk playing on his lips.

Maggie's eyes widened, a blush creeping up her neck as she realized the implication.

"I-I mean, you treat all your students like this," she stammered, biting her lip in an attempt at seductive awkwardness, but the effect fell flat.

The image of her usual tutor, a 70-year-old man, flashed in her mind, and she couldn't help but giggle at the absurdity of it all.

"Not him, obviously," she added, her voice barely above a whisper. "He's, uh, not my type."

Without hesitation, Maggie launched herself at Jeff, her legs wrapping around his waist as he caught her in a tight embrace. The sudden weight and warmth of her pressed against him sent a jolt of desire coursing through his veins. He stumbled slightly, but his grip on her remained firm as he carried her back to the piano. The keys still echoed with the reverberations of their earlier passion, a haunting reminder of what they'd shared mere moments ago. As he set her down, Jeff's hands roamed over Maggie's body, his fingers tracing the curves he'd come to know so intimately.

"Let's try to make this a little more... instructional," he purred, his lips brushing against the sensitive skin of her neck, "I want to show you all the ways I can play this particular piece."