Riley - New Year's Eve Surprise

Christmas came and went. Everyone joked all day about how tired I looked, making cracks at me being young and not used to getting up early with the kids and blah blah blah. I wanted to tell them, “I snuck out last night and got fucked by a college guy,” but I didn’t, I just smiled and agreed.

My panic over being accidentally barebacked by Evan when the condom broke had worn off after about 48 hours, or maybe just because the extended family had left and I was able to drop my pants and jerk off in my own bed again. Of course, dick in hand my mind went back to the camper and how Evan’s thick dick pushed deep inside me, how great it felt having him piston his dick inside me, and he blew his load in me without me knowing but now that I was jerking off thinking about how warm it felt to have his cum inside me I knew every little detail of how that felt. I blew my load all over my stomach imagining how good it must have felt for him to feel me raw and pump his load into me.

I used some tissues to clean up the mess and went to sleep. I repeated this session for the next couple of nights.

On New Year's Eve, some of the girls I worked with had invited me to a house party just off campus over at Penn State. It wasn’t far from me, so if I ended up needing a ride home I was sure I could get one. I don’t usually do random house parties, but I knew the boyfriend who was throwing the party and he wasn’t like a frat bro or anything and the girls promised it would be a low-key party.

I wore black jeans, white briefs, and a red thermal shirt that hugged my tight body. I wasn’t expecting anything to happen, at most, I figured I would kiss one of the girls when the ball dropped because no one at this party was going to be gay and since my coworkers didn’t know I was gay I wasn’t trying to out myself by getting drunk and trying to kiss one of the roommates that lived at the house.

The girls picked me up around 9 and we were at the house party by 9:30. Sean, the guy throwing the party was a small Peurto Rican guy, very cute, skinny fit, sexy smile, straight, and dating my coworker Nicole. One of his roommates was out getting pizza and beer, Sean said his other roommate “went back west for the break” so there was a spare room if any of us needed to crash for the night.

Over the next hour, I smoked a bunch of weed and nursed a beer, I’m not much of a drinker and these college guys had good weed.

More people arrived, two couples who seemed to be friends with my other coworker Anilisa and her boyfriend Tye who was a very sexy black guy who was going to Penn State on some sort of work-related scholarship from his high school job, but I would’ve guessed sports with how fit he was.

Around 11:00 we were all having fun and Alexander, the roommate with the pizza, finally showed up, with a friend in tow.

“Guys, this is my friend Evan, we went to high school together and he’s visiting for the holiday. Evan, this is everyone,” Alexander said, using his head to guesture to everyone and carrying a stack of pizza to the kitchen.

Evan and I made eye contact right away, my heart skipped a beat. I watched him make his way through the room introducing himself to everyone. When he got to me I wasn’t sure what to do or say.

He stuck out his hand, “Hi, I’m Evan,” he said.

My eyebrows raised so far up on my face I’m surprised they stayed attached, did he just introduce himself to me? I shook his hand, “I’m…uh…Riley,” I tried to pull myself together and keep calm.

“Nice to meet you,” he said and moved into the kitchen.

What the actual fuck? I could feel my blood start to boil, how could he not me? Not remember breeding me just a week ago? My mind was doing mental jumping jacks, back flips and all kinds of cardio I don’t like to do. I realized it’s possible he was just pretending to introduce himself so he didn’t have to explain how we know each other, I get that, but it’s also possible he actually didn’t remember me. Like, what if he fucks guys so often, and has a specific type that looks like me, that he genuinely doesn’t remember me? I started to spiral.

No, I refuse to believe he doesn’t remember cumming inside me. You can’t be the first and only guy to cum inside me and not remember me, I’ll remember him for the rest of my life. I felt myself gripping my mostly empty beer a little too hard. I stood up from the arm of the couch I was sitting on and probably too loudly announced that I was going into the kitchen for another beer.

In the kitchen Evan was talking with Anilisa and her boyfriend. I calmly went into the fridge and got myself another beer. Slowly and quietly so I could make sure Evan had a chance to get a good look at me and remember who I am. As I moved around them to dispose of the bottle cap I tried to make eye contact with him, surely that would trigger something, but he was caught up in whatever they were talking about.

I lingered for too long without inserting myself in their conversation, and without grabbing Evan’s attention I decided to just take the “L” and go back to the rest of the party and try to enjoy myself.

With moderate success, I was able to distract myself from Evan, but every now and then I would hear him laugh or catch a phrase that he would say to someone else that snag my attention and frustrate me to no end.

The ball dropped at midnight with Dick Clark narrating the festivities in Times Square. In this house, the couples all kissed each other and everyone cheers, clinking red solo cups, and hugged with the excitement of the adventures awaiting 1999. For the first time in the night, Evan made a point of getting my attention to clink beer bottles and wish me a happy new year. I took a sip from my bottle and made eye contact with him for the first time since he dropped me off at my house last week. I still couldn’t tell if he recognized me or not.

Over the course of the next hour, everyone had some shots, some people left and our host went back to his room with Nicole where they were definitely having sex. The other roommate and his girlfriend were playing beer pong against Tye and Anilisa. I decided it was time for me to go, so I went to the bathroom and debated who I would ask to give me a ride home.

I opened the bathroom door and found myself face-to-face with Evan. He grinned at me, his eyes glassy from the weed and booze. I couldn’t help but smile.

“Oh, sorry,” I reached out and grabbed his firm waist to move him out of my way so I could get by, but he didn’t budge. He looked over his shoulder down the empty hallway, then looked right back into my eyes.

“I really didn’t expect to see you here tonight,” his smile grew.

I felt my heart beating through my chest, “I…I didn’t think you remembered me,” I admitted.

Air burst from his lips, “how could I forget,” he cocked his head in a way that asked me to agree that what happened between us was unforgettable.

I nodded, “yeah, I thought…well, never mind,” I shrugged, still holding his muscular hips in my hands.

He looked over his shoulder again, then back at me, then slowly leaned in for a kiss, which I accepted like a dog in heat. Quickly moving my hands up his body, feeling his defined lats and up to the back of his head to pull his kiss as tight as possible into me and aggressively shoved my tongue into his mouth which he accepted and wrapped his arms tight around me. Fuck this felt good.

A ping pong ball bounced into the hallway and we broke our kiss quickly, expecting someone to come chasing it down the hall. Seconds later Tye came and scooped it up, smiled at us standing like deer in headlights at the bathroom entrance, then went back around the corner. Evan held back a laugh, he reached over for the first closed bedroom door knob, it was locked and you could hear the gentle moans of Nicole riding Sean’s dick. Then we stumbled down the hall and found the unlocked bedroom door and ducked in, slamming the door a little loud and locking it.

Evan aggressively pushed me against the wall and started kissing me and feeling me up. I wrapped my arms around his neck, standing on my tippy-toes so I could reach him standing up straight. He tugged at my thermal shirt, stretching it and pulling it off over my head, and tossed it onto the floor, pulling me over to the bed and pushing me down. I was able to watch him pull his sweater and undershirt off in one swift motion. He went for his jeans and dropped them to the floor and stepped out of them, his checkered boxers tenting from his hard dick.

I tried to follow suit, unbuttoning my pants quickly and opening the zipper. Evan reached for my hips and pulled the jeans down to reveal my white briefs which were barely hiding my hard dick. Tossing the jeans to the floor he crawled up between my legs which I wrapped around his waist as he came in for more kissing and bitting my lip as his animal instinct kicked in.

We both moaned, me a little louder than I should have feeling his hard dick rubbing mine through our underwear. I wanted him so badly, I let him chew my lip and then nibble my ear and my neck enough to leave a hickey that I would worry about later.

“Fuck,” I groaned.

He moaned into my neck, “I want to fuck you again,” he licked my ear.

I wrapped my legs around him tighter, “umm, me too,” I groaned.

He planted a few more kisses, then popped up and shimmied off his boxers. I reached for the waistband of my briefs and slipped them off my ass and he grabbed them around my knees, lifting my legs and yanked them the rest of the way off. Then he leaned in and humped me, letting his hard dick get a good feel of the area as he continued to kiss me and turn me on.

He spit on his fingers and rubbed one on my hole, pushing the tip in and giving it a wiggle. I was so horny it didn’t take much to open up for his finger, my body wanted him inside me and was in the perfect state of buzz to easily relax as his second finger made its way in with ease. He quickly added some spit to his cock and started feeling the head around to try and push in.

“Wait, see if there's lube and a condom in the nightstand,” I told him.

He groaned and shifted over to the single nightstand at the side of the bed, pulling the drawer open quickly as the contents inside all sifted to the front from the inertia. He felt around, pulling out a couple of items that might be lube but were not, and then he pulled out a magnum condom and showed it to me.

“There’s no lube though,” he said. “And this is going to be big on me,” he warned with a cocked eyebrow.

“We’ll make it work,” I pulled him back down to kiss me.

We made out for a few more minutes, teasing each other with our naked bodies. He rolled me over to my stomach and spread my ass cheeks, spat, and rubbed it into my hole with the head of his dick. I moaned as he teased my hole, turning me on even more if that was possible. He dropped his head down and gave my hole a lick which I moaned instantly at. I had never had my hole licked. He did a thing where his flat tongue would glide over my hole and then it would change shape and poke gently into the hole as he added more saliva as lube.

I couldn’t help but gently arch my ass up a little to try to get more of his tongue into me. He went for it too, really getting inside me the best he could, pulling my cheeks apart and digging in.

“Mmm, fuck that feels good,” I moaned, arching my ass up even more.

He palmed my ass cheeks with both hands, massaging them slowly, his thumbs pulling at my hole gently, licking and spitting a little more, then I felt him shift around and straddled my ass. His bigger balls dangling onto my balls, he slowly jerked his cock, lubing himself up and teasing my hole with the head which sent tingles through my body as my ass instinctively tried to pull him in, but I managed to stop myself.

He tore open the condom and I watched over my shoulder as it easily rolled down his cock, even with his girth it was barely stretched. The owner of the condom must have a massive cock. Evan spit on his dick and lubed the condom and then started to feel for my hole, easily catching the ring and he pushed the head in. Even with all the horniness and being so turned on by the rimming and just the idea of being fucked by this hot guy again, my ass clenched at the entry of his cock head and it stung a bit.

“Just breathe,” he whispered.

I nodded my head and buried my face into the pillow, which smelled like dude. Evan slowly pushed all the way in, the sound of the condom crinkling and being stretched by my tight hole was the only sound in the room, nearly drowned out by the music out in the living room and the voices of people playing beer pong.

When I felt his pubs brushing against my ass as he bottomed out I let out a moan, “Mmm, fuck.” I reached my hands back to feel his slightly hairy muscular ass as it flexed to push every millimeter of his cock into me. He lay flat on my back, his warm breath on my neck as he moaned from the pleasure of my tight hole.

“Oh my God…Riley,” he groaned.

I arched my ass up to get more of his thick dick, “mmm, fuck Evan.”

He kissed my neck and started to rock his hips, his dick slowly moving out an inch and then back in to the hilt. Evan only gave me a few gentle thrusts before he started aggressively humping me, holding my shoulders so he could dig his dick as deep as possible with every thrust and holy shit did it feel good.

I started moaning, it felt so good. His muscular naked body grinding his dick deep into me, the heat of his body, the heat of his hard dick inside me. Every thrust grinding my cock into the bedspread below us. I rocked my hips with his thrusts, my ass meeting his hips was making more noise than we wanted but there was no way we were going to stop.

He was breathing hard in my ear and picking up the pace, “fuck you feel so good,” he moaned, and then his dick slipped out of the condom which was tucked tight in the vise that is my hole. He sat up quickly, pulling the condom from my hole and sliding it back onto his dick. It was rolled out now and long, so it was a bit baggy and bunched up at the base of his dick as he pushed back into my hole which got a louder moan from me.

“Oh fuck, ungh,” I groaned, reaching around pulling his ass into me with one hand and using the other to pull his head into my neck so he could kiss and suck on me.

“Mmm, fuck Riley,” he groaned and started fucking my hole a bit harder until his dick slid back out. “Fuck,” he laughed and sat up straight again. He pulled the loose condom from my hole again, “this thing is like a parachute,” he laughed.

I twist my upper body and looked over at what looked like a joke condom over his rock hard dick.

He leaned down and kissed me on the lips again. Then gently opened my mouth and pushed his tongue in and we made out for a few minutes before he looked me in the eyes, “Do we even need a condom?” He nibbled my ear, his saussage rubbing between my buns, taunting my hole.

I rubbed his neck and ass again, “of course,” moaned, arching my ass to meet his non-penetrative thrusts.

“We’ve technically gone without before,” he licked and kissed my neck.

“Mmm, I know but…” I tried to finish the thought as I felt the garbage bag rubbing between my cheeks.

“It felt so good before, didn’t it?” he sucked my neck adding another hickey.

“Ungh, yeah, so good,” I groaned.

I felt him shift his weight and pulled the condom off, his raw dick sliding between my cheeks again.

“You want to do it again, feel my dick inside you…skin on skin?” He whispered, now kissing the other side of my neck.

I couldn’t really think, my body was reacting and my brain was useless, “mmm, yeah,” I moaned.

“Yeah?” He asked again, and I heard him spit in his hand, lubing his dick some more, searching for my hole.

I just nervously nodded, “just, pull out to cum ok?”

“Mmmhmm,” he kissed my shoulder blade as his head started to push into my hole raw.

“Ungh,” I groaned loudly, feeling my hole open for his bare cock. He pushed in slowly until his cock was balls deep in my hole, “mmm, fuck,” I moaned.

“Fuck that feels good,” he made slow circles with his hips, grinding into me, “so good,” he moaned.

“Mmm, fuck Evan, fuck me,” I mumbled.

He didn’t hesitate to ramp right back up to full on fucking. Quickly his hips were making that claping sound against my ass cheeks and it was audible. My moans started to pick up with every thrust, it felt so fucking good I couldn’t help it.

Evan clamped a hand over my mouth and started really digging me out in a way I had never been fucked before.

“Fuck Riley, this feels so good,” he whispered in my hear.

I moaned into his hand, it really did feel amazing, even better than when we fucked in the camper. I arched my ass into his thrusts the best I could but his massive thighs were straddling my hips and his weight on me had me pretty well pinned down to the mattress. I moaned even louder into his hand as his thrusts started hitting my prostate like a boxing speed-bag.

“Ungh, mmm, mmfkk” I mumbled into his hand which clamped tighter as he tried to shush me and then added more pleasure with his cock.

“Fuck Riley, I’m getting close,” he moaned in my ear, his hot breath tingling my skin as his dick increased in size in my hole.

He held his hand tight over my mouth, his other gripping my shoulder as he pounded my hole and moaned into my neck.

“Mmm,” I moaned, pulling on his ass with one hand and his neck with the other hand.

“Oh fuck, I’m cumming,” he nearly shouted, slammed his cock into me and it twitched inside me, unleashing molten hot cum deep inside my slick hole. His entire body seemed to pull tighter into me, clamping on and breeding me as deep as possible.

“Ungh,” I groaned and instinctively arched my ass up for him to unload into.

“Uh, mmm,” he twitched inside me, pulled halfway out, and slammed into me to let out a few last spurts of his load in me and then twitched and went limp on top of me. “Fuck,” he whispered, barely audible and his body twitched again on me.

He let go of my mouth and I took as deep of a breath as I could with all his weight on me. I felt so good. His cock slowly deflated inside me and the tightness of my hole pushed it out along with some of his cum.

“Wow,” he huffed out of breath, then kissed my neck again.

“Yeah,” I huffed with him.

He slowly rolled off of me onto his back. I rolled onto my back and he instantly started stroking my cock.

“You didn’t pull out,” I was thinking in my head but accidentally said out loud.

“I couldn’t, it felt so good last time I…just needed it, I couldn’t control myself and…I popped in you,” he stroked me harder.

I flexed my hips into his handjob, feeling his cum leaking out of my hole and smearing between my ass cheeks, “oh shit,” I felt my abs tighten and thought about him thrusting into my hole and purposefully cumming in side me, and my cum burst from my cock hitting my chin and my chest. Evan kept stroking me all the way through my orgasm, my cum dribbling onto his hand and smearing all over my cock as my body convulsed with the last of my orgasm.

“Oh man,” I smiled.

He leaned in and gave me a quick kiss, then he smeared the cum on his hand onto my abs. “Ew,” he laughed.

“Ew?” I joked, “your cum is inside me,” I laughed.

“Well yeah,” he smiled, “that’s where I want it to be,” he kissed me again and we both lay there catching our breath.

We lay there for about twenty minutes, basking in what had transpired. Someone tried to jiggle the door knob and we both popped up quickly. We grabbed as much of our clothes as we could find, skipping underwear, and just putting on jeans and tops. I used his boxers to wipe the cum off my stomach and he went to the door, unlocked it, and spied down the hall.

“Coast is clear,” he said, opening the door wider and the sound of the party came wafting in.

I went to the bathroom quickly and washed as much of the cum off me as I could with a hand towel. Then rejoined the party for a minute.

“Well, I have to head out,” Evan said to everyone.

“Oh, do you think you could give me a ride?” I asked.

He gave a smile, “Sure, I’m heading out now though.”

We left, not much was said and we just listened to the radio and drove back to my place. He didn’t need the directions as he remembered from last week. As I was about to get out of the car, he pulled me back in. I thought he was going to kiss me, but he reached into the pocket of his jacket and pulled out a balled-up pair of white briefs.

“These are yours right?” He smiled and handed them to me.

I grabbed them quickly, a little embarrassed for some reason. “Yeah, thanks.”

He reached into the back of his car and pulled out a notebook, writing his number on a piece of ripped paper, “I’m here until next weekend, maybe we do this again?”

I turned five shades of red, “yeah, cool,” I didn’t know how to react, having never even been on a proper date but this guy has now cum inside me twice. I bit my lip, then leaned in to kiss him, one solid long kiss.

The next morning I had hickies all over my neck. My mom told me I shouldn’t spend my time with girls that would do that to me. I couldn’t help but laugh at her and tell her not to worry about those girls.