Charmed Season 5 Episode 3

Preach! I love Phoebe. She grown so much. Cole yes 100% has his flaws but they did him dirty. He’s tried to be better and grow and the writers just keep throwing curve balls at this man 🙄

Mara Smith

I just want to say I agree with you 100% on the Cole thing as Cole is my favorite character in Charmed and I will be honest I am not a big fan of Paige because of that. Phoebe is my favorite sister but I was upset by her treatment of Cole though they should of had him explain that he was possessed by the source. And your right about the powers as is Marcus Williams(ep2).

Ian Caudillo

I'm watching the TV series "Once Upon A Time" and it's like in this episode.

Candice

It was a great comment nothing bad I understand sorry I didn't think you said I hated Phoebe just bad wording on my part. You made very good points and this episode helped me understand them much better. Please keep the comments coming different opinions help me appreciate the show more in my opinion.

I Still love Your reaction i didn't put that comment to say you Hate Phoebe not at all i know you love the girls but when i saw your reaction to episode 1 &2 from season 5 , you were always on Cole side , i can understand but i was just sad that you didn't try to understand Phoebe too , like i've said , you can love someone but still want to stop everything because you know its not good for you anymore, like i've said i like Cole want he was & work with the Team but here i think Phoebe have the right to want to make an end . Anyway still love your reaction (its was not to put a bad comment but just because i was a little sad about your reaction everytime Phoebe have said something about it)

Marion Daim

Love the comment yeah its a crazy situation no matter what side you're on. In the end of course I choose Phoebe's side but it sucks because they moved on from when he was Balthazar he even gave up his powers. The Source did really messed things up just like I knew it would. The problem I face now is any other dude that enters Phoebe's life I'm going to immediately hate. But we can all agree the fact that we can feel so connected to these characters is testament to how great this show is. Thank you again for comment

I usually don't comment on your videos, since I'm more of a silent watcher lol. I understand where your coming from and it's interesting to see your pov on Cole/Phoebe since I lean more towards the sisters and Phoebe side. I really empathise with Phoebe because it wasn't the first time Cole manipulated her. Their entire relationship was built off of lies he created to kill her and her sisters. Despite Prue's suspicions, she pursed the relationship and was devestated when she found out Prue was right. She believed in his love more than she believed in her sisters and decided not to vanquish him, even getting back with him when he showed up a few episodes later and begged her. When he became the source, she repeated history by ignoring Paige and distancing herself from her sisters. Even though I don't think it was his fault, being manipulated/abused emotionally and physically (I say physically because he tried to get her pregnant by using those chocolates without her consent and then allowed the Seer to poison Phoebe and the baby with the tonic) by someone who you loved enough to leave and abandon your sisters for, not once, but twice, would make anyone want to erase the person from their lives. While it wasn't his fault, being treated like that for months is traumatic and can't be fixed that easily. If he really wants her back, he's going to have to do more than coming around to apologise and beg for her back like he did in season 3. P.s. I enjoyed your reaction!

Luna