Charmed Season 4 Episode 8

They got me nasty my heart stopped lol im glad somebody agrees about Darryl. I see where Emma is coming from completely i would feel the same way but Cole is my boy so im biased and will side with not killing him eveeytime

And good luck with the promotion!

Adina

Such a blessing to come home from work and watch this. I was WHEEZING through the entire episode. Love the vibe. Died when you got so pissed because you thought she vanquished Cole. Absolutely love how you are as invested in this show as i am

Adina

I like Cole as a character, he’s cool, but his demonic side is definitely integral to what he is so it’s only fair he faces the consequences sometimes especially regarding his victims. I love the show for not glossing over his complexity and his duality between good and evil.

Nao Mi

I kinda always liked that Paige felt this way about him. She hasn't known him the way the others have.

Simone Poinga-Hill

I like how the personal lives of the Charmed one seem to move forward, with Piper thinking of kids and Phoebe wondering if she could ever be married. And now, having Cole as a human, definitely changes things.

Great episode, damn this season is just so good. They did it so well making you think Emma vanquished Cole, when it was only the power stripping potion. I'm glad you did try and see it from Emma's perspective before you thought she killed Cole. What he did is inexcusable no matter the kind of person he is now. For Paige, Cole being a demon was more of an abstract idea, this is the first time she's been confronted with the reality of what he's done. I did love Piper standing up for Cole though, it shows how much he has grown. Piper isn’t blinded by love like Phoebe, she’s watched Cole grow and believes in him and you could tell how much that meant to him. Also, I agree they don't use Darryl enough, it is one of the criticisms I have of the show.

Dannielle

Hmm... I was already kind of afraid you wouldn't be able to see this from Paige and Emma's perspectives. Cole killed hundreds of innocent people. That's not okay. They've just never really talked about it at all; everyone was sweeping it under the rug for Phoebe's sake, really. I know as a character we've come to love Cole, but that absolutely does not change the fact that he has killed so many innocent people. "Belthazor" is not a separate entity or consciousness. That's just Cole's demonic name and form, albeit with less access to the human half's morality. That's what made Cole killing the witch last season such a big deal. And Emma had every right to want to kill him for murdering her fiance. While that is a complicated situation for the Phoebe on an emotional level, it doesn't mean Emma isn't absolutely right. For her, they're all just protecting the person who murdered the love of her life in cold blood. Same for Paige. Paige only just learned in this episode that Cole is a murderer. Her reaction and perspective of Cole is very understandable, and if anything, is less compromised and more objective than Phoebe and Piper's. Also, just a side note... if you could not refer to female characters you don't like as "hoes" or "bitches," that would be better.