Yeah I agree that this show is pretty overhated. The hate kind of started with Kiroto's sister and the incest-y side plot. Which, I totally get that it's not something that everyone wants to watch, but it's unfortunate that one "fault" in the whole show turned from "don't watch if you don't like" to "the show is trash"
I mean there's technically another part of the show that also gets criticised a lot, but that's kind of different due to how even some of the SAO fans tend to say that they agree with it. But it's, in the end, quite a minor thing so nobody really cares about it enough to actively complain about it.
great reaction as always <3