Mixed Bag of Holding: M&M Taste Test

Emily and Murph are literally the blueprint for love. Murph is so indignant the entire episode but the second Jake tries to give Emily an M&M she can't eat he's ready to protect her from it

tiff

I am glad Murph defended milk chocolate from Caldwell's slander. What an absolute joy of an episode.

Jenna H

Caldwell “I really like almonds that’s why I like mounds” you mean almond joys rejected step-brother that notoriously doesn’t have the almonds

Sean Johnson

Caldwell is a Sanderson fan

Jesse Dunlap

“It’s not a journey, it’s a commute” -Jake, tasting an m&m

wizard wearing a poodle skirt

Oooh noooo they've got wheat flour in them. That's so weird :(

Noah Jay

Oh, I know. I'm American but mum's Canadian, so we visited her side regularly. And for some reason (maybe Hershey's being jerks?) Nestle candies are less common here than in the UK and Canada. I'll have to keep an eye out at the international section to see if I can grab a box without buying online. I also found like 4 more flavors of M&Ms at Target this week.

Noah Jay

You’ll have to mail her some, because Smarties in the US are a very different thing.

Elizabeth Lees

I've never heard of MnMs in a tube, but as a kid I got mini MnMs in a little cardboard box, like the ones lunchbox sultanas (rasins) come in. Those were kinda fun.

Squishy, Pawpaw's Brushtail Possum lover

I've only tried classic, mini and peanut, had no idea there were so many flavours

Squishy, Pawpaw's Brushtail Possum lover

Em has mentioned being Celiac before

Squishy, Pawpaw's Brushtail Possum lover

I loved Murph making sure Em wasn't going to eat the (I believe) brownie one. When I was dating someone with a peanut allergy I swear I was more attentive to checking things were nut free than they were.

Squishy, Pawpaw's Brushtail Possum lover

Considering the ones she avoided, my guess is Celiac / gluten intolerance.

Michael Nokes

Caldwell: "Don't worry folks we're not psycho nobody is going to rate anything under a 5." Jake immediately after that statement: "yeah I'm gonna have to go with a 4 on this one" absolute chaotic energy love these episodes so much

cobb saladbar

Why couldn’t Em have so many?

Holden Spencer

I really relate to the way Emily rates things. My friends hate it 😂

Kendra Waters

The "Gaslight Murph into an aneurysm for the bit" joke is very funny for exactly 20 minutes

MrMach6

Murph - "real ass nut in here" "no nut cloning going on here" classic

Matt Atkinson

Welcome to mixed bag aka Murph freaking out for over an hour

Joelle H

props to murph for always playing the role of angry sane person

Julie V Eckert

Jake: "What's the mean?" Caldwell: "There is no mean all M&M's are friends"

Bodhi Milledge

Given a loose idea like “M&M Taste Test” and the gang hits the classics: gaslight Murph, chastise Jake, Caldwell makes some weird strong opinions, and Emily just makes up her own game.

All Pulp! No Juice!

Pretzel M&M's are great. I love 'em. They are my faves. I love when you get a really salty one. Peanut is my second. Glad they liked the pretzel ones!

Gotta get Emily some Nestle Smarties, they do have different flavor shells!

Noah Jay

What types to they taste? I want to join along and find the same ones!

Mary Colligan

Crispy M&Ms we’re the very best. Love that crunch

Elizabeth Morgan

Whoa emily is literally psychic

Vampire the Assquerade

Emily - I got a bag of mini m&ms today because of your hot take and I have to agree - they are pretty awesome

I love these kind of mixed bags because it's like Murph is a real person being tormented by Muppets.

Jessica Olsen

Go Syracuse! Emily was definitely right about the Orange and Blue and I would like to award her an honorary Som&melier certificate from Syracuse University!

Mike Cathcart

Eminemily

Scott