I've never played the game or seen any of the game, but I've really liked both season's so far. However, I think this is the weakest episode so far. I agree with both the scene with the scars and this didn't feel like a finale. But I'm okay with Ellie's flip-flopping feelings. It seems to me consistent with her character in general and the mistakes of youth, a general lack of ability to look forward, always dealing with the now.